Thomsons has played a key role in a recent High Court decision that reinforces the importance of freedom of speech and public interest journalism.
The firm acted pro bono for two leading public interest organisations in the case that had important implications for investigative journalism, whistleblowing and freedom of expression in Australia.
The case centred on footage secretly recorded by animal rights organisation Farm Transparency after activists trespassed on private property and installed cameras inside an abattoir.
The abattoir owner took legal action in the Federal Court, securing damages for trespass. However, the Full Federal Court went further, finding that the abattoir owner should own the copyright in the footage through the imposition of a constructive trust and assignment of the rights.
That ruling raised significant concerns about the potential for copyright law to be used to suppress public interest reporting, including by restricting the rights of journalists and others who were not involved in obtaining the material unlawfully.
The High Court overturned the constructive trust, recognising the importance of considering freedom of speech, political communication and the rights of third parties when determining appropriate legal remedies.
While the Court upheld an order requiring Farm Transparency to destroy its copies of the footage, its decision prevented the abattoir owner from acquiring ownership of the copyright that could potentially have been used to pursue journalists, broadcasters and others who subsequently published the material.
The decision reinforces an important distinction: unlawful conduct can attract legal consequences, but remedies for that conduct must also take account of their potential impact on freedom of expression and the wider public interest.
Thomsons acted for the Human Rights Law Centre and the Alliance for Journalists' Freedom, which participated in the High Court proceedings as amici curiae (friends of the Court).
The amici argued that allowing businesses to acquire copyright in material obtained unlawfully could have far-reaching consequences for investigative journalism and whistleblowing, potentially preventing the disclosure of information the public has a legitimate interest in knowing.
The High Court endorsed the substance of their submissions concerning the need to consider the impact of equitable remedies on the rights and freedoms of third parties and broader public interests, including freedom of speech.
The judgement, Farm Transparency International Ltd v The Game Meats Company of Australia Pty Ltd [2026] HCA 42, is an important development in Australian law, highlighting the need to balance the protection of private property rights with the public interest in freedom of communication.
The Thomsons team was led by Media Partner Marlia Saunders and included Senior Associates Joel Parsons and Amelia CausleyTodd, who instructed Hamish Bevan SC, Jessie McKenzie and Paul Farrell of counsel.
Thomsons is proud to have supported the Human Rights Law Centre and the Alliance for Journalists' Freedom in a case that has helped clarify the legal protections surrounding public interest journalism and freedom of expression in Australia.